Alkarii wrote:I completely forgot about Shelly... I've been having a tough time remembering things the past few days.
But then, if Shelly was born on Earth, wouldn't she technically be native? I know, I know, still a sphinx. However, something that occurs to me...
If each repeated version of Shelly died (I'm assuming that the first one is the one who became the Sage), then... Wouldn't she be Schrödinger's Sphinx?
Shelly's an Earth-native, yes. And, she actually did live through the 80,000-year duration of the Time Loops... but she did so while she was in the Time Forest, which is both outside Earth (and so immune to the Time Loop effect), and is also "backwards". Its time-line is separate from that of Earth, and most of its connections to Earth's timeline are wired up "in reverse".
The Shelly who became (and is now) The Sage,
is the Shelly from the final time loop/ She's the same Shelly that we read about from the very beginning of Wapsi Square.
While living in the Time Forest, and slowly transforming into her sphinx form, she met the other Shellys (or their equivalents) from the earlier time loops... but in what we'd normally call "reverse order".
The last one that Shelly-the-Sage met, was Shelly #1, from the timeline which hadn't even been through its first time-loop. This Shelly (#1) is the person who pulled the sword from the stone, cut down the tree, put the artifact back together, and died of radiation poisoning.
The Shelly-sage-sphinx who wept over her body, picked up the artifact, and was then returned to the normal Earth timeline was the final Shelly (#56 or #57 depending on how you count it). She "returned" to her own timeline in the very instant she'd left it... unchanged, except for total loss of clothing, substantial growth of hair, and acquisition of 80,000 years of new memories.
So. yeah, she's a special case. Not quite a Schrödinger's Sphinx, but one with a lot of lives! She ended up learning some things about what happened in the earlier time loops (from Phix, Nudge, and her earlier selves) but since she was traveling backwards in time (and she was trapped in the Forest) this didn't do her all that much good.
I've always suspected that she might have been able to use this knowledge to "tamper with the past" (persuading Nudge to change the final time loop so that Shelly would never become trapped in the Forest) and chose not to do so because it would create a paradox. Instead, she told Nudge to lure her (Shelly's) younger self into the wilderness during her vision quest, to nearly die, and thus create Conscience (who was Shelly's companion and protector in the Time Forest). Shelly chose to accept her exile, rather than trying to prevent it... and I see that as a Heroic decision (and it's a big part of why I asked Paul to draw "Time in the Time Forest").
The whole "timelines run in reverse order, except for that convergence at the end" and "which Shelly is it?" is kinda subtle, and it wasn't really clear to all of the readers when it happened (read the comments!). The first hint about it, when it happened, was what Shelly said as she was dying... that she had to get back... "... the Calendar Machine." This wouldn't have made sense if this was the
last Shelly, since the CM had already been destroyed... but it would make sense for the
first Shelly to want to get home to prevent the CM from looping time for the first time.
The Sphinx then said "You were the first, as I was the last" and that made it a bit less unclear.
Understanding? Yes? Good. Zathras would not want you to be confoosed.