Wdot wrote:This one is a gory episode, but in my opinion not as bad as Bud punching M's heart out. Anyone else feel that way, why or why not?
The two incidents are different enough that I'm having trouble comparing them on a straightforward good/bad/worse axis, and we don't yet know what this one is all about.
Bud's sucker-punch-to-the-heart was deliberate, calculated, very intentional, and intended for a speciic purpose... to shock Monica out of her denial. Bud saw it as part of her assigned duty ("tough love" of a sort) and knew that it wouldn't actually damage Monica. (Well, actually, she was only kinda somewhat mostly sure of this... she was taking Shelly's word for it to some extent). It was still a somewhat risky thing to do (Monica had never actually regenerated from death before), it was very manipulative (its only purpose was to rattle Monica's state of mind) and Monica resented the hell out of it afterwards for these reasons.
What Phix just did... we really don't know the "why" of this. We don't know if this is yet another training koan etched in blood, or a very genuine rage on Phix's part (and, if the latter, why Phix hates vampires so much). We don't know for sure that Phix actually was knowingly directing that blow at Monica, or whether M just get in the way of a vampire-shredding swipe. We don't know if this is some sort of setup by Brandi, or (if so) whether Tsillah was in on it or was just duped into inviting the vampires to the Library.
M's death here could have real
meaning (genuinely intervening to save two vampires from being genuinely slaughtered by a genuinely furious sphinx, in an attack nobody saw coming) or it could be yet another manipulative sucker-punch.
If this is "real", then it's "less bad" than what Bud did, in a way (it wasn't cynically manipulative, and Monica might just possibly have saved two not-entirely-evil vampires). But, it would be "more bad" because of what it would say about Phix, her rage, how much her rage can control her, and what this will mean for her relationship with Monica and the others.
There. Glad to clarify situation. Zathras would not want you to be confoosed.
