Page 1 of 1

A Timeline Problem

PostPosted: Tue Jun 26, 2018 3:05 am
by jwhouk
We know that when we first met Atsali, she told Katherine she was 15 years old.

Later that year, around Christmas time, we find out that Castela is in Kindergarten.

Typically, kids are about five or six years of age at that point. This means that there is a nine year age gap between Atsali and Castela.

We now have Cass at 15. 15 plus nine is 24.

Unless Atsali is having major studying issues at Dragons Wall, she should be graduated by now - possibly even with a master's degree in whatever field she chose (from what we know from flash forwards, she became a writer).

So my question is twofold: what's up with Atsali, and what year exactly is it now, in the strip?

Re: A Timeline Problem

PostPosted: Tue Jun 26, 2018 11:10 am
by TazManiac
The recent Atsali pictures on eBay refer to her in a 'Librarian' context, so... muh-bee she be grow'd up now.

Re: A Timeline Problem

PostPosted: Thu Jun 28, 2018 12:24 am
by lake_wrangler
That's what so jarring, about time skips: unresolved loose ends. So many questions, so many unknowns...

Re: A Timeline Problem

PostPosted: Thu Jun 28, 2018 2:23 am
by Dave
lake_wrangler wrote:That's what so jarring, about time skips: unresolved loose ends. So many questions, so many unknowns...

Much like life...

Re: A Timeline Problem

PostPosted: Fri Jun 29, 2018 12:44 pm
by lake_wrangler
Dave wrote:
lake_wrangler wrote:That's what so jarring, about time skips: unresolved loose ends. So many questions, so many unknowns...

Much like life...

At least, it's somewhat "expected" of life, unlike a story that you read, where every so often you end up with yet another time skip... how many is that, now? 3? 4?

  • Atsali moving from new Queen Bee to Senior year (comic where it happened, Nadette had coaxed Atsali into doing something in public, via foot rub...) while Castela moved from 6 or 7 to about 10. No news from Atsali's old supporting cast (her retinue in high school). Atsali soon moving to college. New (tea pot) member introduced, along with Atsali's roommate. New job, Atsali more comfortable with her own body image.
  • Castela moving from 10 to 13 -- moving into puberty, rose bushes for hair, possible love triangle, ghost hunting club, with only one actual ghost hunt completed (if you can call it that)
  • Castela moving from 13 to 15 -- "mammalian bumps", love triangle still unresolved (still at the blushing stage... at least, no more rose bushes for hair...)

Did I miss one?

Too many time skips make it hard to keep track of what's going on, when reading a story, if you ask me... Sure, the story is still compelling, but it's also getting annoying to live through, after a while... You get involved, you want to know what happens next, then suddenly you can't as you've moved forward in time and most things are left unsaid!

I'm really starting to wonder if Paul is getting bored with his own story...

When we first shifted to Atsali and Co., we were told that she was the new main character, instead of Monica. Now, it's starting to look like Castela is the main character, yet we never stick around long enough to learn much about her...

Re: A Timeline Problem

PostPosted: Fri Jun 29, 2018 1:50 pm
by lake_wrangler
I do hope that my ramblings don't come across as complaining for complaining's sake...

Consider this, rather, as the cry of someone who cares about the story, is keeping up with it, and wants to know what happens along the way...